Your PR, reviewed twice at 7c93719: Cody's process (codyrancher/ai-skills 5f9619b) and ours, then merged and re-checked. Nothing was posted to GitHub.
Preview: harvesterrulenamer, built from 7c93719, backend Harvester .105 (v1.10.0-rc1 with the resource health controller). Baseline: harvester-main at aa6d11a, same backend.
Both passes found nothing to fix, and Copilot's automatic review agrees. CI is green (7 checks), and Cody and houhoucoop are requested.
Proactive Schedule Suspend fails with the 422 from the issue.harvester-controller-schedulevmbackup.proactive-schedule-suspend, the controller ignores the check under that name, and View, Edit and Delete work from the row menu.| Pass A (Cody's process) | Pass B (our process) | |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | No comments to file | Approve |
| Findings | 0 | 0 blockers, 0 suggestions, 0 nits, 0 questions |
| Checked by both | The 422 on main, the rule created and applied on the PR against .105, View, Edit and Delete from the row menu, one-word names unchanged, the controller matching spec.checkKey. | |
| Only one pass did | Before/after demo videos. Five acceptance criteria from the issue, each with a verdict. A side-effects walk over both callers, earlier rules, the controller, the docs sentence and the backport label. | All 35 check names the controller can write, run through main's and the PR's function: only the 3 schedule names change, and no two collide. 100,000 random names. Both new tests fail against main's function. UpgradeFailed's request captured on both builds. A coverage grid. |
| Left out | The docs sentence about rule names, which you decided to keep. | The ⋮ menu over the dialogs (same on main; see below) and the summary's few seconds of lag. |
| Output | Notes per pass, acceptance files, 2 videos | review.md, coverage.md, checked.md, draft.md, 17 screenshots |
| Cost | In this session | A separate agent: 92 tool calls, about 240k tokens, 26 minutes |
git show in the earlier fix clone, which its brief ruled out. It changed nothing and read no results there.Followed my-pr-full-review in this session, mapped to our setup: the PR preview for his dev server, harvester-main (rebuilt at aa6d11a) for his master build, local files instead of his harness, our recorder for the demos. The before demo's save was a dry run; the after demo used a real rule of mine, deleted on camera. .105 has no rules left.
| Criterion | Verdict | How | |
|---|---|---|---|
| AC1 | Create Ignore Rule works on Proactive Schedule Suspend | Met | Seen on the PR: 201, the dialog closes, “created”. Main shows the 422. |
| AC2 | The rule ignores the check | Met | Seen: ignored by the rule in 0.3s, errors 2 → 1, hidden, “(Ignored)” under Show ignored. |
| AC3 | The other two schedule checks work the same | Met | By test and reading: .105 has no schedule in those states. |
| AC4 | One-word checks keep their names | Met | By test, and Pass B saw UpgradeFailed send the same name on both builds. |
| AC5 | View, Edit and Delete work on that rule | Met | Seen: read-only View, Save only after a change, Delete brings the check back. |
A separate agent that didn't see Pass A. Verdict: approve, 0 blockers, 0 suggestions, 0 nits, 0 questions. What could have blocked and didn't: an earlier rule losing its menu (only the three schedule names change, and those rules were refused before), and the controller not applying the new name (it marked the check ignored with ignoredBy set to it). Its own rule was deleted through the UI.
| Dimension | component-health.js | health.test.js |
|---|---|---|
| correctness | cleared | cleared |
| tests | cleared: both new tests fail without the fix | cleared |
| a11y | n-a | n-a |
| i18n | n-a: the rule name is never shown | n-a |
| conventions | cleared: lint passes | cleared |
| errors | cleared: an unusable name still shows in the dialog's error banner | n-a |
| perf | cleared | n-a |
Nothing. Neither pass has a comment, and it's your own PR, so the reviewers are the next step. If you want Pass A's videos in the PR, I can add them to the description, with the URL bar cropped off as usual.